Speaking the Same Language: Reconciling Marine Ecosystem Currencies

From genes and proteins to pigments and carbon, CBIOMES researchers gathered at MIT Endicott House for a workshop to tackle an unexpectedly (perhaps) complex question: how do we compare the many ways scientists measure life in the ocean?

Reporting by Helen Hill for CBIOMES

The CBIOMES Marine Ecosystem Currencies Reconciliation Workshop, held October 5-8, 2026, at MIT Endicott House in Dedham, MA, brought together observational scientists, experimentalists, molecular biologists, and modelers to examine one of the central challenges in modern oceanography: translating between the many biological “currencies” used to describe marine ecosystems

Across CBIOMES, researchers quantify marine life in a wide variety of ways. Some measure DNA or RNA. Others focus on proteins, lipids, pigments, cell counts, biovolume, ATP, particulate organic carbon, or optical properties. Each metric offers a different perspective on ecosystem structure and function, but comparing results across datasets, methods, and scales remains a significant scientific challenge. The workshop set out to explore whether common frameworks could help bridge these disparate approaches and improve our ability to estimate biomass, characterize ecosystem processes, and inform predictive models.

A Community Conversation About Measurement

The meeting opened with a lively series of round-robin discussions organized around a fundamental question: “How can we, in theory, estimate biomass or define a common currency for comparing ecosystem processes?” Researchers championed the strengths and limitations of approaches ranging from nucleic acids and proteins to pigments, particulate organic carbon, biovolume estimates, cytometry, and optical measurements. Presentations highlighted both the promise and the complexity of translating among these different biological measures.

Subsequent scientific talks provided additional context, including presentations on phytoplankton metatranscriptomics, macromolecular models of mixotrophy, and the biological insights that can emerge when molecular and ecological perspectives are combined.

Bringing Diverse Datasets Together

A major focus of the workshop was practical comparison across multiple field programs. Participants examined data from the Gradients 2, Gradients 4, and Labrador Sea 2025 studies, drawing on measurements that included macromolecular composition, proteomics, transcriptomics, ribosomics, elemental stoichiometry, growth rates, and traditional trait-based observations.

Researchers worked through the assumptions underlying different calculations and explored how estimates of carbon biomass can be derived from proteomic, transcriptomic, and ribosomic observations. Whiteboard sessions encouraged detailed discussion of units, conversion factors, methodological uncertainty, and the practical implications of comparing estimates derived from fundamentally different types of measurements.

These conversations reinforced a recurring theme: no single currency captures the full complexity of marine ecosystems. Progress will likely require frameworks that allow multiple perspectives to be integrated rather than forcing researchers to choose among them.

From Observation to Prediction

The workshop also looked beyond measurement toward modeling. Discussions examined how emerging insights into macromolecular allocation, protein expression, transcriptomic activity, and organismal traits can be incorporated into ecosystem models.

Additional presentations explored large-scale patterns in microbial resource allocation and asked whether molecular measurements could be connected more directly to the trait-based frameworks commonly used in ecological and biogeochemical modeling. Participants considered how these relationships might improve estimates of biomass and function while also generating new approaches for representing marine ecosystems in predictive models.

Building a Shared Research Agenda

The final day focused on synthesis and planning. Working groups revisited two guiding questions: how biomass estimates from flow cytometry, ribosomics, and metaproteomics can be compared and combined, and whether broad patterns in macromolecular and protein allocation can improve both biomass estimation and ecosystem modeling. The meeting concluded with manuscript planning sessions aimed at carrying these discussions forward into future collaborative research.

By bringing together experts who rarely work within the same methodological framework, the workshop highlighted both the challenges and the opportunities that arise when different scientific “currencies” meet. Participants left with a deeper understanding of the assumptions embedded in their respective approaches, new ideas for integrating diverse datasets, and a shared commitment to developing more unified descriptions of marine ecosystem structure and function.

“This is a very timely and important topic as the field seeks to move towards global-scale surveys and better integration between observations and models,” said CBIOMES Director Mick Follows. “The workshop revealed exciting progress within the CBIOMES community towards intercalibration of key currencies used in marine microbial ecology and biogeochemistry.”

Special thanks to workshop lead-organizer Erin Bertrand, the speakers and participants who contributed their expertise throughout the meeting, and the Simons Foundation for supporting this collaborative activity.

Participants included:

Zoe Aarons (MIT), Olivia Ahern (MBL), Ginger Armbrust (UW), Qicheng Bei (USC), Erin Bertrand (Dalhousie), Sacha Coesel (UW), Daria Di Blasi (USC), Stephanie Dutkiewicz (MIT), Nolan Fehon (Dalhousie), Zoe Finkel (Dalhousie), Mick Follows (MIT), Jed Fuhrman (USC), Helen Hill (MIT), Ruby Hu (Dalhousie), Scott Pollara (Dalhousie), Kathy Qi (UW), Yubin Raut (MIT), Elden Rowland (Dalhousie), Joe Vallino (MBL), Patrick White (Dalhousie), Nathan Williams (USC)

Story Image: Attendees of the CBIOMES Marine Ecosystem Currencies Reconciliation Workshop, held October 5-8, 2026, at MIT Endicott House in Dedham, MA, October 2026 – image credit: H. Hill

October 2026 CBIOMES Marine Ecosystem Currencies Reconciliation Workshop: Plenary recordings, agenda, and related links (restricted)